We earn affiliate commissions for purchases using our links.  Learn more

Ice Cream Review: Molly Moon’s Milk Chocolate TOffee (8.5/10)

Contents

Brand

Molly Moon’s

Flavor

Milk Chocolate Toffee

Rating

8.5 of 10

Review

Pint Description from Molly Moon’s website: “Toffee is indisputably one of the top treats we like to find tucked into a silky ice cream. For our Milk Chocolate Toffee ice cream, we make our toffee with lots of butter, organic sugar, sea salt, and then sprinkle Theo 70% dark chocolate on top.

After the toffee is cooled, we break it into bite sized morsels before folding them into our rich milk chocolate ice cream. This flavor is perfect in a cone or cup, or made into a decadent sundae topped with hot fudge or our seasonal orange marmalade jam, with whipped cream and a Chukar cherry on top! You can find this ice cream at all of our scoop shops except for the little Madrona walk-up window. This flavor is gluten-free!”

Milk Chocolate Ice Cream: A very dense base. Tempering improves it, revealing a smooth and creamy texture. It has a solid milk chocolate flavor—strong, but not overwhelming; sweet, but not cloying.

Toffee Chunks: Medium to large chunks of chocolate covered toffee pieces. Quality dark chocolate—Theo 70% dark chocolate. The slight bitterness contrasts and highlights the sweetness of the base. This chocolate takes longer to melt in my mouth compared to the typical ganache-style chocolate used by other brands.

The toffee is still solid, not melted into the base. It’s got a nice buttery, caramel flavor. The biggest chunks are half an inch across. A moderate amount; a chunk in every other spoonful. On the other hand, I appreciate the larger toffee chunks versus having only toffee crumbs.

Overall: A good quality milk chocolate base that plays well with the large toffee chunks wrapped in a bitter dark chocolate. But a more toffee mix-in ratio would’ve leveled up this pint considerably.

Score: 8.5/10

Home Delivery

Nationwide Shipping of Molly Moon’s: Unavailable.

Front blurb

Molly Moon’s Milk Chocolate Toffee

Back blurb

None.

Calories

  • 3 servings per container
  • Serving size: 2/3 cup
  • Calories per serving: Unknown
  • Calories per container: Unknown

Ingredients

Unknown

Purchase Location

Molly Moon’s

Price

$12.00

Books

Need to know how Molly Moon’s does it? Get Molly Moon’s cookbook: Molly Moon’s Homemade Ice Cream: Sweet Seasonal Recipes for Ice Creams, Sorbets, and Toppings Made with Local Ingredients.

Related

Psst! You can make ice cream like Molly Moon’s at home. Here’s Molly Moon’s secret ice cream base recipe! (Spoiler: Molly Moon’s ice cream base is Philadelphia-style, which means it’s egg-free!)

Read all our Molly Moon’s pint reviews.

Read all our other pint reviews.

About The Author