We earn affiliate commissions for purchases using our links.  Learn more

Ice Cream Review: Molly Moon’s Peppermint Cocoa (8.5/10)

Contents

Brand

Molly Moon’s

Flavor

Peppermint Cocoa

Rating

8.5 of 10

Ice Cream Review Molly Moon's Peppermint Cocoa

Review

Pint Description: From the Molly Moon website: “Our decadent cocoa ice cream with chunks of minty white chocolate bark specked with peppermint candies. This flavor is gluten-free!”

Cocoa Ice Cream: Rich and creamy. A milk chocolate base with a subtle peppermint aftertaste. Which is to say: the peppermint isn’t overpowering the chocolate. A nice balance; refreshing from the mild hit of mint.

I’m not sure this base flavor is what was intended by Molly Moon’s. It may be that the peppermint candies on the white chocolate bark mix-in simply melted into the base. Regardless, this combination works well.

White Chocolate Bark Speckled With Peppermint Candies: Rectangles of white chocolate bark, many broken into bits, but also plenty of biggies, some about 1 inch by ½ inch in size. Look at those cross section pics. Yes, this was a great mix-in.

Sweet with a mild white chocolate candy burn. They melt quickly in the mouth. Only a subtle peppermint flavor. I taste salt on the white chocolate. I’m not sure what that is from. It’s another pleasant effect here.

The peppermint candy speckles are not very evident. I see a little red coloring smeared on the white chocolate. Perhaps most of the peppermint on the bark melted into the base.

Overall: Peppermint Cocoa was a seasonal flavor offered by Molly Moon in December 2022. Peppermint ice cream is not my go to, but this is pretty well done—a premium base that subtly balances chocolate and mint. The size and number of the white chocolate bark mix-in is the real standout of this pint, adding texture and decadent flavor. It’s a solid Christmas flavor—minty and refreshing. I hope it returns in 2023. Recommended. 8.5/10.

Home Delivery

Nationwide Shipping of Molly Moon’s: Unavailable.

Front blurb

Molly Moon’s

Back blurb

None.

Calories

  • 3 servings per container
  • Serving size: 2/3 cup
  • Calories per serving: Unknown
  • Calories per container: Unknown

Ingredients

Unknown

Purchase Location

Molly Moon’s

Price

$12.00

Books

Need to know how Molly Moon’s does it? Get Molly Moon’s cookbook: Molly Moon’s Homemade Ice Cream: Sweet Seasonal Recipes for Ice Creams, Sorbets, and Toppings Made with Local Ingredients.

Related

Psst! You can make ice cream like Molly Moon’s at home. Here’s Molly Moon’s secret ice cream base recipe! (Spoiler: Molly Moon’s ice cream base is Philadelphia-style, which means it’s egg-free!)

Read all our Molly Moon’s pint reviews.

Read all our other pint reviews.

About The Author