Caffe Panna Butter Up is the shortbread Girl Scout cookie dream pint. Yes, this pint is just cookies and ice cream. But the base is premium quality—rich, thick, creamy, mildly buttery, very sweet.

Caffe Panna Signs of Spring is a refreshing, sweet-tart treat, a solid springtime, or in my case with an overstocked freezer, summertime treat. The lemon-strawberry base is somewhat lighter than other Caffe Panna pints I’ve tasted, but still premium quality.

Caffe Panna Best Damn Hazelnut is a correctly named pint. It is the best hazelnut flavored ice cream I’ve ever tasted. This pint is totally decadent.

Contents Brand Caffe Panna Flavor Sweet Do Rating 10 of 10 Review Pint Description: Callebaut chocolate chip studded brown sugar

Caffe Panna’s You Win has all the mix-ins of a great pint—marshmallow fluff, caramel, Oreo crumbles, and chopped Reese’s peanut butter cups. But the fatal flaw here is a lack of ice cream base.

Caffe Panna’s Graham Central Dedication is smore’s overload. It’s more mix-ins than base. Don’t get me wrong: all the ingredients are top notch.