Jeni’s Buttercream Birthday Cake is rich birthday cake flavor that doesn’t skimp on the sprinkles. Jeni’s describes the pint as “Buttercream ice cream that’s rich with notes of vanilla and butter and has a decadent, spoon-coating, icing-like texture.

Jeni’s Pineapple Upside Down cake is an inspired pint concept that didn’t quite come together for us. We love pineapple upside down cake, and we think an ice cream pint version would be wonderful.

Jeni’s Salty Caramel is a delicious premium base, but nothing more, not really a fully realized pint. It’s like buying a premium vanilla pint.

A rich, creamy, sweet peanut butter base with the aroma of a candy bar. Not the strongest peanut butter flavor. The taste is sweet on the front with a peanut butter finish.

Buttermilk Base: smooth, rich, creamy, and only mildly sweet so that the slightly sour and tart buttermilk can be tasted. It adds another dimension to the pint, an effective flavor contrast well-balanced against the peach swirl and biscuit chunk mix-ins.

Mint Base: A rich, smooth, dense, buttery, and boldly minty base. It captures the flavor of those semi-soft pastel mint pillow candies you would find back in the day next to the cash register at many restaurants.

Contents Brand Jeni’s Ice Cream Flavor Brown Butter Almond Brittle Rating 7 of 10 Review Base: The base has a

A light, creamy, soft base. Even fresh from the freezer, a spoon cuts through the ice cream with much greater ease than a typical premium pint.