Graeter’s S’mores is the best s’mores pint I’ve tried, largely because of its bold, flawless graham-flavored base. From the first taste, I was nodding “Yes, that’s right! That’s what a s’mores ice cream base is supposed to taste like.”

Graeter’s Caramel Macchiato is a creative flavor from a brand that mostly does classic, old school flavors. I was frankly surprised to find this flavor on their website.

Graeter’s Strawberry Chocolate Chip is pretty good, but could’ve been better. It’s a mild strawberry-flavored pint with only a mediocre amount of chocolate chunks. You may have missed this pint—it was a limited edition available only April – May 2022.

Graeter’s Coconut Chocolate Chip is a flavor combination that I can wholeheartedly endorse. Coconut and chocolate desserts are top tier, first menu choice for me.

Graeter’s Cookies & Cream is a classic flavor, and as I’ve observed before, Graeter’s does the classics very well. The sweet cream base is a fairly pure flavor here because Graeter’s didn’t include many smaller Oreo crumbles in the base that would otherwise have added some cookie flavor to the base.

Graeter’s Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip should’ve been a 10/10. I mean, it’s peanut butter AND Graeter’s chocolate chunks: a combo destined for greatness. What could go wrong?

Graeter’s Buckeye Blitz sounds like a flavor I would love love love—chocolate and peanut butter ice cream base, peanut butter cookie dough, and those wild and crazy Graeter’s chocolate chunks.

Graeter’s Dark Chocolate Brownie does a great job nailing a dark chocolate base—a bold, but not too bold dark chocolate. After scooping many of their pints, I believe Graeter’s does basic flavors very well.