Atomic Creamery’s Strawberry is an old-school take on a classic flavor, with bright pink coloring, a large inviting strawberry slice on top, and plenty of strawberry chunks swirled throughout.

Contents Brand Atomic Creamery Flavor Raspberry Prosecco Rating 7 of 10 Review Disclaimer: Atomic Creamery sent me a free box

Atomic Creamery’s Halvah is an unusual pint. Halvah is a Middle Eastern candy—a dry, crunchy sesame paste bar. I was expecting crunchy pieces of halvah in the base, but nope.

Atomic Creamery’s Buckeye is peanut butter and chocolate heaven. The base is a sweet, creamy, bold peanut butter. So many brands pull their punches with a peanut butter base. Not Atomic.

Atomic Creamery Cherry Cordial is in good company with B&J’s Cherry Garcia and Graeter’s Black Cherry Chocolate Chip. It has a premium sweet cream base, decadent Cella chocolate-covered cherry mix-ins, cherry syrup from the candy that flavors the base to a certain extent, and half a ton of milk chocolate stracciatella everywhere in the pint.

Atomic Creamery’s Red Velvet Cheesecake is a great Valentine’s Day treat. The base has the thin mouthfeel of ice milk, perhaps because this ice cream is made quickly—flash frozen—using liquid nitrogen.