While Acme Valley Mixed Berry is good quality, it is a one note flavor. Including some mix-in—for example, pie crust pieces, butter cookies, or chocolate chunks—would elevate this pint.

I have to admit I do enjoy caramel ice cream and caramel flavors generally. And I enjoyed this pint pretty well. The base and the caramel swirl are both premium quality.

Chocolate and Peanut Butter is a classic combination. The combo works well in this pint, especially with the punchy chocolate base.

Acme Valley’s Espresso is not for the faint of heart. It’s a bold and roasty coffee ice cream loaded with espresso coffee grounds. No punches pulled—COFFEE FLAVOR.

Chocolate and raspberry are a nice contrast. Acme Valley implemented the raspberry flavor well, and I’m really getting into Acme Valley’s chocolate chips.

Mint (Chocolate) Chip—another class done well by Acme Valley. Some might long for something more exotic or novel, but when a classic is flawlessly executed like this, I have no complaints.

Acme Valley’s Chocolate Chip is an enjoyable, classic ice cream flavor. The sweet cream base is high quality and refreshing. But it’s the plentiful, crunchy stracciatella chocolate chips that make this a recommended flavor.

Acme Valley Butter Pecan is a well-executed classic flavor. Acme Valley’s bases are top tier, among the best I’ve ever tasted.