Graeter’s does classic flavors well—and by this point in ice cream history, cookie dough flavored ice cream is a class. Graeter’s chocolate chips work well with the cookie dough chunks.

Graeter’s Toffee Chocolate Chip is a great flavor combination. But my particular pint didn’t have as many mix-ins as I would’ve liked.

: Graeter’s Midnight Snack is a strong contender against Ben & Jerry’s Chubby Hubby. It has a very similar flavor profile to Chubby Hubby—malt base, chocolate-covered pretzel balls, mini peanut butter cups, and brownie chunks.

Graeter’s Black Cherry Chocolate Chip is a solid and very enjoyable premium pint. But ours was somewhat lacking in the chocolate chip department—a likely quality control issue.

Graeter’s Mint Chocolate Chip is a flavor journey on a spoon: first the sweet dense base delights, then the mint hits you with just enough fizz and pop, and finally you savor the dark chocolate chips as they melt in your mouth.

Graeter’s Double Chocolate Chip is a flavor for the chocolate lovers. Yes, it’s a basic chocolate chocolate chip, but it’s executed so well…