Proper Ice Cream’s Vanilla Malt with Roasted White Chocolate is one of the better pints I tried from this brand. The vanilla malt base and roasted white chocolate mix-ins are premium quality.

Proper Ice Cream’s Banana Two-Pound Cake and Cream sounds like a flavor I could really enjoy—banana ice cream with vanilla cream and rich pound cake chunks. But there were multiple serious problems with this pint.

Proper Ice Cream’s Chocolate-Covered Honeycomb worked for me because I have a serious sweet tooth. It is supposed to consist of a sweet cream base with chocolate-covered honeycomb candy pieces.

Proper Ice Cream’s Butterscotch Cocoa Brownie has a killer combo pint flavor—butterscotch ice cream and brownies. But I would have preferred a bolder butterscotch base.

Proper Key Lime Pie is the best of the six pints I’ve tried. Everything just comes together. The base is a strong but not overly bold Key lime that’s never icy.

Proper Ice Cream’s Blueberry Muffin absolutely nails the blueberry muffin flavor profile. It’s composed of a sweet cream base, a blueberry compote swirl, and blueberry muffin pieces.