Ice Cream Review: Graeter’s Strawberry Chocolate Chip (7/10)
Graeter’s Strawberry Chocolate Chip is pretty good, but could’ve been better. It’s a mild strawberry-flavored pint with only a mediocre amount of chocolate chunks. You may have missed this pint—it was a limited edition available only April – May 2022.
Ice Cream Review: Caffe Panna Butter Up (8/10)
Caffe Panna Butter Up is the shortbread Girl Scout cookie dream pint. Yes, this pint is just cookies and ice cream. But the base is premium quality—rich, thick, creamy, mildly buttery, very sweet.
Ice Cream review: Graeter’s Coconut Chocolate Chip (8/10)
Graeter’s Coconut Chocolate Chip is a flavor combination that I can wholeheartedly endorse. Coconut and chocolate desserts are top tier, first menu choice for me.
Ice Cream Review: Little Debbie Unicorn Cakes (5/10)
Little Debbie’s Unicorn Cake ice cream is an overly sweet, artificial strawberry-flavored pint that may delight small children but leave adults wondering if they should be tested for diabetes. If you like that artificial Nesquik strawberry flavor, then you’ve find your go-to pint.
Ice Cream Review: Van Leeuwen Honey Cornbread with Strawberry Jam (8/10)
Van Leeuwen Honey Cornbread with Strawberry Jam is an enjoyable summery pint. It’s a well-executed take on a cornbread ice cream with plenty of big chunks of soft cornbread and a fair amount of cornbread crumbs mixed into the vanilla base.
Ice Cream Review: Proper Vanilla Malt with Roasted White Chocolate (8/10)
Proper Ice Cream’s Vanilla Malt with Roasted White Chocolate is one of the better pints I tried from this brand. The vanilla malt base and roasted white chocolate mix-ins are premium quality.
Ice Cream Review: Graeter’s Cookies and Cream (8/10)
Graeter’s Cookies & Cream is a classic flavor, and as I’ve observed before, Graeter’s does the classics very well. The sweet cream base is a fairly pure flavor here because Graeter’s didn’t include many smaller Oreo crumbles in the base that would otherwise have added some cookie flavor to the base.
Ice Cream Review: Proper Banana Two Pound Cake and Cream (6/10)
Proper Ice Cream’s Banana Two-Pound Cake and Cream sounds like a flavor I could really enjoy—banana ice cream with vanilla cream and rich pound cake chunks. But there were multiple serious problems with this pint.
