Ice Cream Review: Graeter’s Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip (7/10)
Graeter’s Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip should’ve been a 10/10. I mean, it’s peanut butter AND Graeter’s chocolate chunks: a combo destined for greatness. What could go wrong?
Ice Cream Review: Proper Chocolate Covered Honeycomb (7/10)
Proper Ice Cream’s Chocolate-Covered Honeycomb worked for me because I have a serious sweet tooth. It is supposed to consist of a sweet cream base with chocolate-covered honeycomb candy pieces.
Ice Cream Review: Caffe Panna Signs of Spring (7.5/10)
Caffe Panna Signs of Spring is a refreshing, sweet-tart treat, a solid springtime, or in my case with an overstocked freezer, summertime treat. The lemon-strawberry base is somewhat lighter than other Caffe Panna pints I’ve tasted, but still premium quality.
Ice Cream Review: Proper Butterscotch Cocoa Brownie (7.5/10)
Proper Ice Cream’s Butterscotch Cocoa Brownie has a killer combo pint flavor—butterscotch ice cream and brownies. But I would have preferred a bolder butterscotch base.
Ice Cream Review: Caffe Panna Best Damn Hazelnut (9/10)
Caffe Panna Best Damn Hazelnut is a correctly named pint. It is the best hazelnut flavored ice cream I’ve ever tasted. This pint is totally decadent.
Ice Cream Review: Proper Key Lime Pie (9/10)
Proper Key Lime Pie is the best of the six pints I’ve tried. Everything just comes together. The base is a strong but not overly bold Key lime that’s never icy.
Ice Cream Review: Cafe Panna Sweet Do (10/10)
Contents Brand Caffe Panna Flavor Sweet Do Rating 10 of 10 Review Pint Description: Callebaut chocolate chip studded brown sugar
Ice Cream Review: Graeter’s Buckeye Blitz (8/10)
Graeter’s Buckeye Blitz sounds like a flavor I would love love love—chocolate and peanut butter ice cream base, peanut butter cookie dough, and those wild and crazy Graeter’s chocolate chunks.